Previously:
Andrea canceled dinner, and Lucia’s name followed Ellie through a house showing until the distraction threatened her sale. She decided one trip to the library would fix the problem.
New to the Serial? Start Here | Need the previous chapter? Chapter 6: Worn Out
Carol
I don’t want to be at the mercy of my emotions.
I want to use them, to enjoy them, and to dominate them.
~Oscar Wilde
I would have preferred more time before seeing Andrea again, but he had insisted on meeting early the following morning. He picked my favorite bistro in Del Mar. Sitting through a place he hated for my sake made the trap feel almost affectionate. The crowded tables and bright morning light left me no graceful way to seduce him, which explained why he had suddenly developed a taste for an audience. Desire had become a reflex that no longer gave me leverage.
Still, our children would have been beautiful. Genetics deserved credit even when romance did not. The fault wasn’t his, though I would have loved to blame him. I had never truly wanted him that way, no matter how well I performed enthusiasm.
Over the summer his prettiness had settled into a soft masculinity that disturbed the illusion I preferred. He was becoming a man. A lovely development for whoever wanted one.
As soon as I reached the table, the polite choreography began. Andrea stood and gave me an air kiss without letting his skin touch mine. How sanitary. He could probably announce an execution and then remember to hold the door afterward to let them carry out the corpse.
“How are you?” His voice had that deep, velvety softness that made every word feel intimate, as though he were speaking beside my ear instead of across the small table.
“Good,” I said. All that velvet, and he still sounded like a man preparing to place something fragile in the trash without making noise.
Once, he had encouraged my ambitions. His face used to brighten when I described a hard sale or a listing I had stolen from someone older and less deserving. So that morning, I launched into every closing, commission, and possible new client. He listened patiently, asked the appropriate questions, then gave a single nod, calm and certain.
That calm certainty made me think of Lucia. Her fumbling honesty would have been easier to manage. Around her, I understood the balance of power.
Andrea remained kind even when he controlled the terms of our relationship. Wealthy people often mistook gentleness for proof that they had harmed no one. His manners never failed him, and neither did my ability to detect bullshit.
Still, I smiled and gave him the polished version. No bitterness. No accusation. A woman who plans to keep using a bridge should resist the urge to set it on fire.
“I may pick up another listing in La Jolla,” I said. “The owners are relocating.”
“That sounds promising.” He took a sip of coffee. So odd. His weak stomach had turned him into a tea drinker long ago.
“Very.” So I gave him every exquisite detail of the property. If he wanted civility, he could suffer for it.
He had never belonged to me in any meaningful sense. Hard to give something meaning when I had invested so little in him. Still, Andrea had belonged to me enough to flaunt, and that had served its purpose for two years. God, he was so fucking beautiful and polished.
Men wanted to become him or take him to bed. Some probably lacked the imagination to choose. Everyone envied me. Of course, I would miss that. I look beautiful next to anything, even a sack of potatoes. Andrea simply had the advantage of being couture.
As soon as I stopped talking, I saw the decision in his eyes. We both knew why we were there. The only uncertainty was which one of us would force the ending into the open.
“Carol.” He said my name in a low, steady voice that felt less like affection and more like goodbye. “I’ve been thinking about us. Where we are. What we want.”
We? Perhaps he meant his parents. They had wanted him married yesterday, although he was still a few months short of nineteen.
Then again, he might have meant himself. Andrea rarely told anyone what he wanted, and I had never asked. “Yes?”
An elegant smile arranged itself across my face. For one dangerous second, I considered making a scene. Part of me still clung to the protection his name offered. Without him beside me, the world would begin asking questions I had worked very hard to avoid. He looked sorry, but not uncertain.
Pity offered nothing to work with. Of course he remained at the table, but the stillness of his face told me he was already gone. His parents had raised him to complete unpleasant obligations properly. Relief moved beneath my fear. It wasn’t like I could keep pretending he was a girl.
“I care about you,” he said. “I’m grateful for our time together. But we both knew it was ending.”
Andrea had never lied. He made no promises he couldn’t keep, which explained why he had never said he loved me. My throat tightened anyway. The tenderness irritated me more than cruelty would have. Callous nonchalance would have justified a scene. Kindness required composure.
I lifted my drink and took a slow sip before asking, “Is there someone else?”
He waited too long to answer. “It doesn’t matter.”
Explanations gave desperate people something to attack. Andrea had finally learned not to hand me ammunition. Smart of him.
“No,” I said softly. “I suppose it doesn’t.” The softness cost me nothing and might prove useful later. “You want to end it.”
“Yes.” There was no opening.
“We should have ended it before you left in June.” The line came out smooth enough to convince anyone listening. Another breath, and I would believe my own words. If I could believe I had released him first, the ending would still belong to me.
All that mattered was that he would remember I had behaved well. I nodded with practiced grace. “I don’t have the promise ring with me.”
Andrea had given me a lot of jewelry without conditions, but the promise ring was different. His parents had always treated it as a family loan, no matter whose finger wore it. Maybe the girls had been right about the ring; keeping it would be petty. More importantly, returning it would make me look principled.
“Come by after my class tomorrow,” I said. “I’ll have it waiting.”
“Of course.” He gave me a gracious smile, as though he hadn’t just closed the chapter on two years of our lives.
Andrea pushed his bangs behind his ears. He always made that insignificant gesture when he was ready to be done. Perhaps our history was worth the trouble of holding onto it. Connections survived on good manners long after love became inconvenient.
Though our breakup had been civilized, even elegant, I wasn’t ready to go home. Not to my mother’s sour disapproval, nor to the weight of her silence. I drove to Del Mar North Beach and parked facing the water. But the sea breeze didn’t clear a thing. I kicked off my shoes and walked down to the shoreline. The backwash dragged the sand from beneath my heels, and the whole coast seemed to slide with it.
Freedom wasn’t supposed to feel like vertigo. But it did. Because my cover was gone. The story I’d been writing for the world was now missing its crucial piece: Andrea.
Coming out? Still no. Not in San Diego. Not while anchormen and priests took turns calling AIDS God’s verdict on the gay community. Maybe one day. Definitely not now. I wasn’t interested in social or financial suicide.
But I could add a new line to my plan. Step five: build a different life. The last step, the one I had yet to write down.
My heart tripped at the thought. Yes, a life with someone who needed me and couldn’t just walk away. Ever. And there was no one more perfect than Lucia for that life. She would trade her life for safety.
First, I had to find a way to buy the Craftsman cottage before someone snatched it from under me. Hillcrest was San Diego’s gay ghetto, so it was the safest place for me. And safety was as close to freedom as I hoped to get.
And the house, God, Lucia would love it. The little stone walkway split the front yard. Raised vegetable beds on one side. Wildflowers on the other. The backyard was a small patch of grass. Enough for a table, a pair of chairs. Sun-drenched. Ours.
The driveway fit two cars, but I already knew how to make flaws look temporary. I was the only one who drove, but the bus stop sat only six houses away, close enough for her to mistake access for freedom. Absolute perfection.
When I finally pulled into my parents’ driveway, I noticed Penelope and Lucia sitting on the porch swing. She adored that stupid thing. I had to think of a way to add a swing to our porch. Whatever the cost. It would be worth it just to see her face.
Then she turned toward my car.
Makeup covered more than a bruise. Lucia wore lipstick, blush, and a thin line of eyeliner.
I stopped cold. Well. That was fucking new.
Lipstick had nothing to do with her bruises. She had made an effort. For someone.
Who?
Shit.
Yesterday I had climbed every floor of that ridiculous library looking for her. Eight stories of musty books, and not one of them had the decency to give her up.
Now this. Throughout high school, Lucia had orbited me as though I generated the only light worth following. She helped with my homework and covered for me when I lied to my parents, and always came when I called.
Gratitude made her reliable. Devotion made her mine, although neither of us had been tacky enough to say so.
Why change now?
Lucia had never shown an interest in boys. She dated when her grandmother forced her and complained afterward as if a judge had sentenced her to pick up trash along the freeway.
How many times had she mentioned Matteo?
Once. Twice. Maybe.
No. She didn’t like men. I could feel it. I knew Lucia.
Unless Matteo was really a Maria.
My instincts had never failed me when I agreed with them.
Author’s note
The first medical reports appeared in 1981, when physicians identified unusual infections and cases of Kaposi sarcoma, a rare cancer, among previously healthy young gay men. The press christened the mysterious illness gay cancer. Researchers eventually identified HIV as the virus that causes AIDS. Public opinion had already settled on a moral diagnosis.
I remember sitting in my honors English classroom discussing the epidemic with two friends. We all thanked God we weren’t gay.
Yeah, right.
One of us was bisexual. Two were gay. We considered lying to one another an acceptable public health measure.
Young men were dying, effective treatment didn’t exist, and every news report seemed to bring another reason for alarm. Yet back then, we were more afraid of our families’ rejection than the possibility of contracting AIDS. At seventeen, the consequences of disgrace were considerably easier to imagine than those of a disease we didn’t fully understand.
In the Mexican American community I grew up in, a daughter’s sexual reputation could determine whether she remained welcome at home. Pregnancy outside marriage was the most obvious transgression. Getting caught having sex before marriage sometimes carried comparable consequences.
The practical consequences could be devastating. If she was lucky, she received a beating. If she wasn’t, her parents threw her out. We didn’t have cell phones, and many girls lacked money, transportation, or employment. A sympathetic neighbor might offer shelter until a boyfriend’s family or a relative intervened.
Some girls had grown up under extraordinary restrictions. Families regulated their movements, discouraged employment, and required a brother or other relative to accompany them outside the home. Vacations generally meant visiting relatives in Mexico.
The arrangement possessed a particularly vicious logic. A family could cultivate dependence for seventeen years, then demand immediate self-sufficiency as punishment for disobedience. Independence was treated as a threat to a daughter’s virtue until her parents decided she no longer deserved their protection.
Not every Mexican American household operated this way. Some families protected their daughters through scandal, and comadres frequently intervened when parental authority became cruelty. I remember those acts of generosity. But I can’t forget how effectively the possibility of expulsion maintained obedience.
Admitting you were gay introduced another level of threat. AIDS intensified the hostility already surrounding homosexuality. In April 1984, religious demonstrators marched through San Diego’s Hillcrest neighborhood carrying signs that called AIDS God’s punishment. The condemnation had acquired a public address.
Carol possesses freedoms many girls I knew never enjoyed. She earns her own money, drives, and moves through society with considerable independence. Yet Andrea provides something harder to purchase: heterosexual respectability, reinforced by his family’s wealth and social standing. Losing him threatens that protection.
She knows what exposure could cost her, particularly in a society that regarded homosexuality as a disgrace and increasingly associated it with disease. Nevertheless, she allows herself to envision a shared home, a garden, and the ordinary domestic intimacy heterosexual couples could pursue without inviting public condemnation. Hillcrest offers the possibility of a different existence, although even there, safety remains conditional. There’s something profoundly brave about her willingness to imagine that future.
Sources
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “The AIDS Epidemic in the United States, 1981–Early 1990s.” David J. Sencer CDC Museum.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “AIDS: The Early Years and CDC’s Response.” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 60 (2011).
de Anda, Diane, Rosina M. Becerra, and Eve P. Fielder. “Sexuality, Pregnancy, and Motherhood among Mexican-American Adolescents.” Journal of Adolescent Research 3, nos. 3–4 (1988): 403–411.
“The Bible Tells Me So.” San Diego Reader, May 14, 1987.
What did you make of Carol’s reaction to Andrea finally making a decision for himself?
All parts of Beneath the Weight of Water and the first part of Inherited Shame are free for everyone.
Paid subscribers receive early chapter access, bonus scenes, and The Grumpy Writer.
Work arrives by email. No ads. No noise.
Copyright © 2026 Angelica Thorne
For permission requests, contact angelicathorne@icloud.com.




